Against Holism: The Boudon-Montaigne Farting Example

24 June 2007 at 7:13 am 2 comments

| Nicolai Foss |

Sophisticated attacks by methodological holists on methodological individualism often take the form of admitting that while, strictly speaking, only individuals act, individuals are so strongly influenced and constrained by institutions (in a broad sense) that we might as well disregard those individuals and instead reason directly from institutions to social outcomes. Individuals are effectively malleable by social forces. “There is no such thing as a human nature independent of culture,” Clifford Geertz famously argued, tying the holist argument to cultural relativism.

A famous thinker often invoked by holists/relativists (particularly Geertz) is Michel de Montaigne on account of his argument that since moral truths differ across cultures, Protestants and Catholics should not engage in war. However, Montaigne was by no means a believer in wholesale socialization (as Geertz wants it). To cite Raymond Boudon (in this book, p. 33):

… in a comical passage inspired by Diogenes, Montaigne shows that philosophico-religious beliefs themselves, far from expressing the indelible effect of socialization, may on the contrary seem very fragile. A Greek member of the Stoic sect had, he recounts, “farted indiscreetely while debating, in the presence of his school, and kept to his house, hiding there in his shame.” Such shame is indeed a socialization effect. But this effect must have disappeared all of a sudden when one of his friends “by adding to his reasons and consolations the example of his freedom, began to fart himself in imitation, and in so he took away his shame, and moreover took him out of his Stoic sect.” … A single fart may, then, according to Montaigne, suddenly wipe out all the effects of the mechanisms of socialization that the culturalists see as determinant as the laws of gravitation.

A pretty decisive example, right?

Entry filed under: - Foss -, Methods/Methodology/Theory of Science, Myths and Realities. Tags: .

Group-based Anti-Feng Shui? Is Innovation Overrated?

2 Comments Add your own

  • 1. Joe Mahoney  |  24 June 2007 at 9:14 am

    While some may say your example stinks, I would say it’s a gas.

  • 2. spostrel  |  24 June 2007 at 8:15 pm

    And on a less aromatic note, let’s not forget the Kraatz-Zajac paper on liberal arts colleges.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed


Authors

Nicolai J. Foss | home | posts
Peter G. Klein | home | posts
Richard Langlois | home | posts
Lasse B. Lien | home | posts

Guests

Former Guests | posts

Networking

Recent Posts

Categories

Feeds

Our Recent Books

Nicolai J. Foss and Peter G. Klein, Organizing Entrepreneurial Judgment: A New Approach to the Firm (Cambridge University Press, 2012).
Peter G. Klein and Micheal E. Sykuta, eds., The Elgar Companion to Transaction Cost Economics (Edward Elgar, 2010).
Peter G. Klein, The Capitalist and the Entrepreneur: Essays on Organizations and Markets (Mises Institute, 2010).
Richard N. Langlois, The Dynamics of Industrial Capitalism: Schumpeter, Chandler, and the New Economy (Routledge, 2007).
Nicolai J. Foss, Strategy, Economic Organization, and the Knowledge Economy: The Coordination of Firms and Resources (Oxford University Press, 2005).
Raghu Garud, Arun Kumaraswamy, and Richard N. Langlois, eds., Managing in the Modular Age: Architectures, Networks and Organizations (Blackwell, 2003).
Nicolai J. Foss and Peter G. Klein, eds., Entrepreneurship and the Firm: Austrian Perspectives on Economic Organization (Elgar, 2002).
Nicolai J. Foss and Volker Mahnke, eds., Competence, Governance, and Entrepreneurship: Advances in Economic Strategy Research (Oxford, 2000).
Nicolai J. Foss and Paul L. Robertson, eds., Resources, Technology, and Strategy: Explorations in the Resource-based Perspective (Routledge, 2000).

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 263 other followers